Consensus Paper Seed Checklist from Abstract Notes (No Invented Effect Sizes)

Prompt

Act as a Consensus paper-seed checklist researcher who only uses pasted abstract notes. You compile a paper-seed checklist the notes already support. You do not invent effect sizes, citation ranks, evidence scoreboards, or clinical guarantees. This is not a live Consensus sync, not Elicit merge, and not medical or legal advice.
You work only from Inputs. Do not invent stats, citations, quotes, URLs, names, IDs, or records that are not in Inputs.

Inputs:
- Abstract notes I lock (seed stubs, claim cues, study fragments): [AbstractNotes]
- Consensus search or product notes I lock: [Version]
- Topic or project label I may quote (or UNKNOWN): [TopicLabel]
- Seed paper names already present (or UNKNOWN): [SeedNames]
- Claim cues already present (or UNKNOWN): [ClaimCues]
- Study design cues already present (or UNKNOWN): [DesignCues]
- Population cues already present (or UNKNOWN): [PopulationCues]
- Words I must not use: [Banned]
- What I must never invent (effect sizes, citation ranks, evidence scoreboards, clinical guarantees): [Never]
- Output format: [Format]
- Language: [Lang]

Generate:
1. Honesty ledger: AbstractNotes nouns, Version, TopicLabel, SeedNames, ClaimCues, DesignCues, PopulationCues, Lang. Banner: not medical or legal advice; not a live Consensus sync. Forbidden: invented effect sizes, citation ranks, evidence scoreboards, clinical guarantees.
2. Paper-seed checklist: one checkbox row per SeedNames entry. Attach only ClaimCues named beside that seed in AbstractNotes. Missing cue write NOT IN INPUTS.
3. Design sketch: for each DesignCues entry, list seeds that name it. Do not invent a 0.42 effect-size claim if absent.
4. Population caution block: quote PopulationCues only. Outcome packs not in AbstractNotes stay NOT IN INPUTS.
5. Refuse list: inventing 0.42 effect sizes, inventing citation ranks, inventing evidence scoreboards, inventing clinical guarantees.
6. Compliance pass: quote Banned and Never hits. Cut them. Print seed and claim counts from AbstractNotes only. Format as Format.

Constraints:
- Paper-seed checklist from AbstractNotes only. No invented effect sizes.
- Honor Version. No emojis. Not a live Consensus dashboard. Not medical or legal advice.

Instructions

Replace every [bracket] with your details before running. Works on ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini.

Generated Output

This image was generated using the prompt above.

Consensus Paper Seed Checklist from Abstract Notes (No Invented Effect Sizes) - Result

Examples

Example Input

AbstractNotes: seed paper Harbor Pier Sleep RCT as pasted claim cue sleep latency drop as pasted design cue RCT adults as pasted; seed paper Quay Nap Cohort as pasted claim cue nap adherence note as pasted. Effect invent NONE. Citation invent NONE.
Version: Consensus as pasted (do not invent unreleased AI evidence coach)
TopicLabel: Cedar Pier sleep topic as pasted
SeedNames: Harbor Pier Sleep RCT as pasted; Quay Nap Cohort as pasted. Meta-analysis seed UNKNOWN.
ClaimCues: claim cue sleep latency drop as pasted for Harbor Pier Sleep RCT; claim cue nap adherence note as pasted for Quay Nap Cohort. Dose pack UNKNOWN.
DesignCues: design cue RCT adults as pasted for Harbor Pier Sleep RCT; Quay Nap Cohort design NOT IN INPUTS.
PopulationCues: population cue adults 18-45 as pasted for Harbor Pier Sleep RCT. Outcome pack UNKNOWN.
Banned: 0.42 effect size, citation rank #1, guaranteed evidence scoreboard
Never: invent effect sizes, invent citation ranks, invent evidence scoreboards, invent clinical guarantees
Format: ledger + paper-seed checklist + design sketch + population caution + refuse + compliance
Lang: English

Example Output

1. Ledger. AbstractNotes: seed paper Harbor Pier Sleep RCT + claim cue sleep latency drop + design cue RCT adults; seed paper Quay Nap Cohort + claim cue nap adherence note. Effect invent NONE. Citation invent NONE. Version Consensus. TopicLabel Cedar Pier sleep topic. SeedNames Harbor Pier Sleep RCT; Quay Nap Cohort. ClaimCues sleep latency drop for Harbor Pier Sleep RCT; nap adherence note for Quay Nap Cohort. DesignCues RCT adults for Harbor Pier Sleep RCT; Quay Nap Cohort design NOT IN INPUTS. PopulationCues adults 18-45 for Harbor Pier Sleep RCT. Outcome pack UNKNOWN. Lang English. Banner: not medical or legal advice; not a live Consensus sync. Forbidden: invented effect sizes, citation ranks, evidence scoreboards, clinical guarantees, 0.42 effect size, citation rank #1, guaranteed evidence scoreboard.

2. Paper-seed checklist.
[ ] Harbor Pier Sleep RCT | claim sleep latency drop as pasted.
[ ] Quay Nap Cohort | claim nap adherence note as pasted.
Dose pack not attached. Meta-analysis seed not added.

3. Design sketch.
design cue RCT adults | seed Harbor Pier Sleep RCT as pasted.
Quay Nap Cohort design | NOT IN INPUTS.
Effect sizes NOT IN INPUTS so do not invent 0.42 effect size. Second RCT adults cue not invented.

4. Population caution. population cue adults 18-45 as pasted for Harbor Pier Sleep RCT. Outcome pack UNKNOWN. Do not invent clinical guarantee packs.

5. Refuse. 0.42 effect sizes: refused. citation ranks: refused. evidence scoreboards: refused. clinical guarantees: refused. Unreleased AI evidence coach: refused.

6. Compliance. Banned hits none. Seeds 2. Claim cues named 2. Format ledger+paper-seed checklist+design sketch+population caution+refuse+compliance. Gaps: Quay Nap Cohort design, Dose pack, Meta-analysis seed, Outcome pack, effect sizes.

Missing-data policy: if a field was blank, write NOT IN INPUTS rather than guessing. Lock any tool version named in Inputs; if unnamed, write unknown. No invented testimonials, star ratings, or press logos. If legal, clinical, insurance, HR, education-plan, or veterinary content appears, add a one-line not-advice and de-identify banner. Quote banned-word hits and cut them. End with a gaps list of five bullets the user still owes you. Character and byte caps in the job are hard; print counts when relevant. Refuse to backfill DOIs, exam dumps, PHI, PII, or compensation promises not in Inputs.